Malpractice Myths: Reaping What You Sow

The year is almost up, and so far, I’ve had over a hundred Texans contact me and ask for me to help them file a medical malpractice case in their home state.  My license and practice are in Utah…so why are they calling me?  Texas is a big place, so why can’t they find a lawyer to help them a little closer to home?

They tell me they’ve tried.  They say they’ve called dozens of Texas lawyers, but because of that state’s rigorous, pro-insurance “tort reform” measures, there are fewer and fewer lawyers who are able to help injury victims pursue justice.  Certainly, there are still plenty of attorneys in Texas, they’ve just shifted their focus to other areas of law.

I previously wrote that the real goal of so-called “medical malpractice reform” is not to decrease health care costs or improve the quality of medical care, it is to escape the consequences of negligence.  Once the attorneys are gone,  negligent physicians will be able to act with impunity; there will be no one to hold them accountable.

As you might expect, the rate of medical negligence in Texas is on the rise, but injured patients have little or no recourse.  Additionally, data shows that the new laws didn’t solve the “doctor shortage crisis” that lobbyists claimed.

Meanwhile, the State of Illinois held that damage caps were unconstitutional over two years ago.  And what’s the result?  Has there been an explosion of “frivolous” lawsuits?

Nope.

The facts won’t change the rallying cry of insurance companies and corporate healthcare lobbyists.  You can rest assured that with each upcoming legislative session, they will be trotting out the same, tired old myths in an effort to get politicians to take your rights away.

Breast Cancer Awareness Ride

As a medical malpractice attorney, I have represented dozens of women and their families in cases involving delays in treatment for breast cancer.  Those cases have taught me about the courage of women facing this terrible disease, and that early detection and treatment are critical.

On a personal level, I have a mom, a wife, and a daughter.  Statistically speaking, breast cancer will affect at least one of them. That is why breast cancer awareness and support for research are important to me.  That’s one of the reasons why I encourage you to join me in this Saturday’s Breast Cancer Awareness Ride sponsored by the fine folks at Trek Bikes of American Fork.

You can register for the event right here (there are 25 mile and 10 mile options) and get more information from the Trek Bikes of American Fork web page.  This is an outstanding event, and in addition to being a great time, it’s an important cause.

 

The Thin Line Between Negligence and Crime

Attorneys for a Utah physician convicted of distributing opiate narcotics to his patients for no legitimate medical purpose have asked the court to dismiss the case based on accusations of prosecutorial misconduct.  You can read the article here.

This case illustrates just how thin the line can be between negligence and criminal conduct.  Not all cases of medical malpractice are crimes, even when they involve narcotics.  As a Utah medical negligence attorney, I have represented many clients in civil cases involving the negligent prescription of narcotic painkillers.  Some of these cases involve separate criminal actions as well which are pursued by local and federal law enforcement agencies.

In these cases, there are a number of hidden pitfalls for unwary patients and inexperienced attorneys.  The negligent physician’s insurance company may try to escape responsibility by denying coverage and forcing injured victims to seek restitution in the parallel criminal proceeding.  At minimum, the negligent doctors’ attorneys will try to delay the civil case for years, pending the outcome of the criminal matter.  This delay can cause catastrophic results for families who have lost loved ones, face enormous medical bills, and have smaller household incomes.  Prescription drug use causes hundreds of deaths per year, and leave unanswered questions for the families.  If you’re considering a medical malpractice lawsuit, or just want answers, give me a call for a free, no obligation consultation: (801) 424-9088.

Rolling Rivalry – Riding for a Good Cause

If you live in Utah, then you know that last week was “Rivalry Week,” culminating with the football game between the University of Utah and Brigham Young University.  I am an alum of both schools, but I’ll admit, when it comes to football, I bleed red:This year, my little brother (that’s him on the left) and I had the opportunity to participate in a wonderful event that put the rivalry into perspective.  The “Rolling Rivalry” was a 65 mile bike ride from Rice Eccles Stadium (the home of the Utes) to Lavell Edwards Stadium (the home of the Cougars).  The ride benefited the Angel’s Hands Foundation, a non-profit that provides assistance to help children who have been diagnosed with rare diseases.It was both an honor and a privilege to participate in this fantastic event for a very important cause.  The next event for the Angel’s Hands Foundation is on October 15 and you can click here for additional details.

Health Care Choices Just Got More Difficult

Today the Department of Health and Human Services shut down public access to the National Practitioner Database.  This database used to include general information about malpractice claims.  It was a useful tool for members of the public to make educated and informed decisions about who to choose as a health care provider.  Not only is an important public resource gone, but it just got easier for bad doctors to hide their negligence.

Don’t be a Laughing Stock…

A few weeks ago, as I was walking out of the deposition of one of my expert witnesses in a birth injury case, the insurance company lawyer on the other side and I started talking about the case.  When we were done, he smirked and said something that made me sick to my stomach:

You might have us on this one.  You know, we’ve got another case that’s a lot like this one, the kid has terrible injuries, but the lawyer who represents the baby’s family is just screwing it up.  Our company thought we’d be on the hook for millions, but we’ll probably get out of it for a couple grand.  The attorney usually does DUIs, not malpractice.  He never talked to the important witnesses, he didn’t hire experts on time, and his legal writing is terrible–the judge can’t stand him.  Our doctor may have screwed up, but that lawyer is the one who is committing malpractice.”

I put his comments out of my mind as best I could, but yesterday, I heard something similar from a different hospital lawyer.  We had just argued a motion about compulsory arbitration to the judge, and after the hearing, the hospital’s attorney walked into the elevator with me and laughed.  I asked him what was so funny, and he answered:

Just thinking of another case.  This same issue came up and the plaintiff’s lawyer had no idea what he was doing.  This arbitration statute is complicated, and he couldn’t even find it.  He didn’t know about recent amendments and he sure hadn’t read the caselaw.  We creamed him.  His client will never get as much in arbitration as he would have in front of a jury. We just won that case and it hasn’t even started.”

As I headed back to my office, I thought of those other lawyers and their clients.  The malpractice defense lawyers admitted the clients had strong cases, but that wasn’t enough.  Because the clients chose lawyers who didn’t focus on medical malpractice law, their cases were getting screwed up.  In one case, a birth injury, the catastrophically injured infant client would need millions of dollars to help pay for future medical needs.  Instead, he would be lucky to get a few thousand.

You only need to thumb through the phone book to see how many attorneys there are practicing in Utah.  Many of them are outstanding in their fields.  But for medical malpractice cases, hiring a “jack-of-all-trades” attorney can be a terrible mistake.  Don’t be the next person these insurance defense lawyers laugh about.  If you’ve got a medical malpractice case, hire a lawyer that knows the ropes.

The Right Lawyer for the Job

One of my first jobs was working construction with my dad during the summers when I was in high school.  Although he had a general contractor’s license, he really considered himself a finish carpenter–he was always good with details.  He taught me that even though he could probably figure out how to do the various jobs associated with building a home like the concrete work and the drywall, the overall project would be more successful if he let the specialists do their job while he did his.  “If it were my house,” he said, “I wouldn’t want the electrician putting in my plumbing.”

That was the first thing I thought of when I read the recent reports claiming that “Only 1 in 5 medical malpractice cases pay.”  The news reports refer to the conclusions from a study published in the New England Journal of Medicine analyzing malpractice risks by area of specialty.  Significantly, the authors found that contrary to popular belief, there are actually very few so-called “frivolous lawsuits” filed against doctors.  One of the study’s lead authors, Professor Amitabh Chandra, even said what I’ve known for years: given the time and expense of prosecuting a malpractice case, “a lawyer would have to be an idiot to take a frivolous case to court.

So if frivolous lawsuits aren’t really being filed in the first place, then why are so few cases successful?  I can’t help but think that many of those cases were not being filed by the right lawyer for the job.  Just as my dad wouldn’t build a house with an electrician installing the plumbing, people injured by medical negligence should be wary of hiring just any lawyer to handle a medical malpractice case.

I don’t do divorces.  I don’t do bankruptcies.  I don’t practice criminal law.  My practice focuses exclusively on serious personal injury cases, with an emphasis on medical malpractice.  These cases are among the most complicated forms of civil litigation.  The laws are complex, and so is the medicine involved.  You can’t afford to hire a lawyer that isn’t experienced in medical malpractice law with a demonstrated track record of success against the insurance companies and attorneys that defend negligent doctors and hospitals.  If you or a loved one have been injured by medical negligence, make sure you get the right lawyer for the job.  Call Utah medical malpractice lawyer Ryan Springer at 801-424-9088 for a free, no obligation consultation today.  Don’t let your case be one of the many that are won by careless physicians and their insurance companies.

Health Care Negligence and Keeping Secrets

Health Leaders Media recently reported that a startlingly high percentage of health care providers fail to disclose their errors due to fears of reprisal or retaliation.

As a medical malpractice lawyer, I’ve never understood why hospitals and health care corporations don’t just admit their mistakes and compensate the injured patient.  They would put my colleagues and me out of business in an instant while drastically reducing malpractice costs, insurance premiums, and other expenses.

It’s almost like it is a big game to these corporations.  They would rather waste hundreds of thousands of dollars covering up mistakes and paying high-priced defense lawyers for years of litigation than simply admitting a mistake and paying malpractice victims a fair amount for their medical bills, pain, and suffering.

I just don’t get it…

Killer Pain Killers: Prescription Drug Malpractice

Today a jury found physician Dewey MacKay guilty of forty counts of illegal distribution.  This conviction follows the recent guilty pleas entered by two other Utah doctors, Warren Stack and Max Cannon.  The actions of these physicians were deemed to be not just negligent, but criminal.

All three of these doctors were dispensing powerful analgesic drugs–painkillers–in high amounts.  Analgesic drugs are commonly used to relieve pain. Some analgesics, such as aspirin and acetaminophen, are relatively mild and are available over the counter.

Other analgesics, however, are powerful narcotics, and are available only with a prescription. Some common prescription analgesics include morphine and codeine, which are naturally occurring opiates; hydrocodone (Vicodin and Lortab) and oxycodone (OxyContin and Percocet), which are semi-synthetic opioids; and fully synthetic opioids, such as Fentanyl and Methadone. Under the close supervision of health care providers, these drugs can play an important part of a patient’s pain management regimen.


Unfortunately, these drugs can also cause serious side effects, from nausea and constipation to respiratory arrest and even wrongful death. Additionally, due to their narcotic nature, there is a high propensity for addiction and abuse. Dr. MacKay, Dr. Stack, and Dr. Cannon were all using their patients’ addiction for selfish reasons.  Other doctors, however, are also over-prescribing these drugs, or improperly supervising a patient’s pain management regimen.  While this is not criminal activity, it is medical malpractice.  Negligent prescribing and monitoring of painkillers can cause serious personal injuries and give rise to medical malpractice claims.

Sometimes, careless physicians can transition patients from one narcotic painkiller to another, with disastrous consequences. For instance, Methadone is metabolized very slowly, and has a half-life of 15-60 hours. Additionally, it is fat soluble, and can remain in your system longer than other drugs. Likewise, OxyContin, a popular brand of oxycodone, is formulated to be released over time (the name is an abbreviation of Oxycodone Continuous release). When a patient is taken off of a “slow” drug and transitioned to a fast acting, instant release version, overdose can easily occur. The results of overdose can include respiratory arrest, anoxic brain injuries, or even wrongful death.

If you or someone you know has been over-prescribed painkillers by a doctor, you should contact a medical malpractice attorney immediately.  Our legal team has successfully handled many cases of medical negligence involving narcotics, and we can help you get the answers you need.  Call today for a free, no obligation consultation: 801-424-9088.

 

Tagged ,

NBI Seminar: Social Media in Personal Injury Discovery

Social media is rapidly becoming a way of life for all of us.  But what are the implications of this explosion of technology in personal injury litigation?


Join me on Wednesday, September 7 for a 1.5 hour teleconference discussing discovery issues related to social media. You can register now at NBI.